Blanchard Grinding vs. Precision Grinding
If you’re looking to enlist the help of a metal fabricating shop, you may be interested to know the types of services they offer. You’ll likely already be passingly familiar with the names of some of these services, and you might even have a bare-bones idea of what these services entail. If you’re like most individuals, however, you probably don’t know much more, because you’ll rarely need expertise beyond this. Even if you place an order with a machine shop, all you’ll likely see is the finished product. But what if you want to know more about the process behind creating this polished result?
Today, we want to explain one of the processes many metal fabricators use to help create the finished products they deliver to clients. This process is known as grinding, and we’ll talk about what it involves, as well as some of the different variations you may encounter and the advantages and disadvantages each method has to offer.
What Is Grinding?
Grinding is technically a subset of the cutting processes many metal workers and fabricators use. Like all cutting processes, it is designed to trim and shear away unwanted sections of metal that will not be part of the final product. By this definition, it has much in common with other types of cutting or trimming, even outside the metalworking industries.
Beyond these initial similarities, however, we can see grinding also has many differences when compared to other types of cutting. Because of these differences, grinding usually gets categorized as part of the finishing process. It often comes into play toward the end of the fabricating process, rather than at the beginning when the body of the product is coming together. But what exactly does grinding do?
Grinding is a process that uses abrasive action to hone metal parts and components to the exact required dimensions, as well as improve overall surface quality. Grinding shapes the surface by removing excess amounts of metal per project specifications. How does this work? In most cases, machine shops use a grinding wheel equipped with an abrasive edge. This wheel spins directly against the side of the metal being shaped, and the abrasive edges slowly cut away pieces of the metal, grinding it down to the exact shape required.
What Is Grinding For?
Metal fabricators primarily use grinding for shaving away unwanted pieces of material to make the resulting product fit exactly with the needed dimensions. Metal fabricators typically employ grinding to perform this function instead of other types of cutting because grinding wheels can remove the tiniest metal shavings. Typically, other cutting tools can only remove metal in larger chunks.
Metal grinding has another purpose in addition to this trimming and shaving, however. It can also help finish off a metal surface, smoothing down the metal and removing ridges, abrasions and aberrations in the surface. This process is also technically a kind of shaving, but the purpose is less about removing pieces of metal and more about giving the metal surface a clean and even finish. While grinding as a method of metal removal will likely take place as an earlier step in the fabrication process, this type of finishing is much more likely to come near the end.
The great strength of metal grinding is that it offers the gift of precision. Depending on which method of grinding the metalworkers use, these machines can easily perform the most minute tasks with almost exact perfection. This accuracy allows machine shops to create precise, small parts that all fit together exactly to create the desired final product. Not every type of grinding specializes in this precision work, but the process has a reputation for bringing this strength to the world of metal fabrication.
What Are the Different Types of Grinding?
We’ve mentioned there are several different types of grinding, and that each of these types brings something a bit different to the process. None of these grinding techniques are inherently better or worse than any of these others. Rather, they can each be extremely useful when employed at the right moment and in the right circumstances, and each has a unique list of pros and cons.
While the manufacturing and metal finish applications deploy numerous grinding techniques, two of the most common processes are Blanchard grinding and precision grinding. Let’s take a closer look at each of these two processes now.
What Is Blanchard Grinding?
Blanchard grinding is a system developed by and named after the Blanchard Machine Company of Cambridge, Mass., in the early 20th century. This system offers a fast and exceptionally cost-effective method for removing large amounts of material over an expansive surface area. While it isn’t quite as precise as other grinding techniques, it’s still more accurate than most cutting methods, and is furthermore effective over large surfaces.
Also known as rotary surface grinding, the Blanchard technique involves the use of either magnets or specially designed holders that secure the component and hold it in place. Machine operators pair this setup with the Blanchard grinding machine, which consists of a wheel that mounts on a vertical spindle. This spindle rotates the wheel in the opposite direction of the magnets holding the object. This way, the grinding occurs only along one side of the working piece. Once the grinding is finished, a Blanchard machine leaves a distinctive pattern of cross-hatching across the ground surface, adding an extra visual element to the final appearance of the object.
Blanchard grinding is most frequently a tool of metal workers, who use this method to shape ferrous metals — those which contain iron. It isn’t the only possible application, however. Blanchard grinding also works with some non-ferrous metals and even certain plastics, although these two latter applications typically involve higher costs and slower production times. Because of these two drawbacks, most metalworkers only use Blanchard grinding for ferrous metals.
Blanchard Grinding: The Pros
Why might a metal fabricator choose to use Blanchard grinding over the alternative grinding methods available to them? Here are just a few of the benefits of picking Blanchard grinding.
- It’s fast: Other grinding methods take a bit more time to achieve their precise and accurate results. What Blanchard grinding offers, however, is speed. Metalworkers can complete this process quickly and efficiently, which makes the whole process of shaping the final product more efficient.
- It’s cost-effective: Perhaps the most concrete benefit of Blanchard grinding is its cost-effectiveness. The financial advantage comes because this process is speedier than its competitors, as well as because of the significantly greater horsepower it employs, further enhancing its efficiency.
- It’s terrific for large surfaces: Some grinding methods are better for small spaces, where they can bring all the precision of a fine-toothed comb. Blanchard grinding is different, however, as it does its best work when it’s grinding away large chunks of material from extensive surfaces.
Blanchard Grinding: The Cons
Blanchard grinding offers plenty of benefits to those who choose to use it, but it isn’t a perfect system, and there are plenty of situations it cannot handle. Here are just a few of the limitations you’ll want to be aware of with this system.
- It’s less precise: Grinding of any type is for precision work, and Blanchard grinding is no exception. The fact remains, however, that out of all the different grinding methods, the Blanchard system is among the least precise. Because of this lack of accuracy, machine shops will only use this process for projects that have a tolerance of over 0.001 inch.
- It leaves a grinding mark: Most people think the unique cross-hatching pattern left behind by Blanchard grinding is very visually appealing. If the metal in question needs to be blank and free from any markings, however, this will be an undeniable drawback.
Examples of typical Blanchard grinding applications include finishing large sections of plate stock, castings, forgings, stampings, rotary tables and die blocks.
What Is Precision Grinding?
Blanchard grinding is often the undisputed best choice when it comes to high-volume projects involving objects with a large surface area. When it comes to delivering on a higher level of accuracy and working with smaller parts that require a more delicate touch, however, Blanchard grinding often falls short. For these and other projects, the best choice is precision grinding.
There are several different methods of precision grinding. This term doesn’t denote a single type of grinding, and rather refers to a subset of grinding methods that all prioritize extreme levels of precision above all else. Here are a few examples of grinding techniques that fall under the umbrella of precision grinding.
- Horizontal surface grinding: This system uses a high-speed rotating wheel deployed on the flat surface of a part or component.
- Cylindrical grinding: Cylindrical grinding provides a smooth surface finish on round objects.
In a typical precision grinding process, a wheel grinds the surface down to the exact specifications of the project, all while using the utmost precision. In addition to this shaping and shaving, however, this grinding process produces a smooth surface unmarked by bumps, ridges or patterns. This surface is then ready for a paint or powder coating, or left as-is.
Like Blanchard grinding, precision grinding is primarily a tool of metal fabricators. Just a few examples of materials that are compatible with precise grinding include silicon carbide, aluminum oxide and zirconia alumina.
Precision Grinding: The Pros
What makes precision grinding the best choice for a variety of different applications and situations? Here are a few of the reasons metal fabricators are choosing precision grinding for their work.
- It’s precise: The name alone makes it clear what this process offers as its most impressive and defining characteristic. This type of grinding offers exacting accuracy. Metal fabricators can use this process to replicate the most specific and minute of measurements, even down to the tiniest fractions. For precision grinding, no scale is too small to deserve and receive attention.
- It’s versatile: As we mentioned, precision grinding doesn’t refer to only one type of grinding and instead includes a whole category of grinding processes and machines. That makes it a versatile category, capable of working with a variety of shapes and materials. Whether you’re looking to work with flat or curved surfaces, precision grinding is up to the task.
- It provides a smooth finish: Blanchard grinding is well-known for leaving its trademark cross-hatched pattern across the surface it grinds. While this pattern often adds an extra element of visual interest, it may not always be great for the product in question. Precision grinding, on the other hand, leaves a smooth surface that’s perfect for finishing with paint or a powder coating.
Precision Grinding: The Cons
Precision grinding is an excellent tool that’s just right for a variety of applications, but it isn’t always ideal for every situation. In some cases, other types of grinding might be better for the job at hand. To demonstrate this, here are just a few of the limitations of precision grinding to be aware of.
- It’s best for small applications: Precision grinding is fantastic at working on a small scale, but it isn’t always the best choice if you’re looking to work with large pieces of material where you want to shear off significant chunks of material. For applications like these, you’ll usually be better off with Blanchard grinding.
- It isn’t as fast as Blanchard grinding: Blanchard grinding can work so quickly because it isn’t as precise. Precision grinding achieves levels of accuracy Blanchard grinding can’t, but it sacrifices speed in the process. If speed is more important than accuracy for a project, the metal fabricators will more likely opt for Blanchard grinding.
Blanchard vs. Precision Grinding
Which is better: Blanchard or precision grinding? We hope it’s clear this isn’t a question with a consistent and clear answer. Both have remarkable strengths, but neither can handle every project a metal fabricator might encounter. Rather than asking which of the two methods is better, however, it’s far more useful to ask which is more appropriate for the task at hand.
Blanchard grinding will nearly always be the better choice for large tasks where speed is a priority, and tiny details and precision work aren’t quite as crucial. On the other hand, if you’re dealing with things on a small scale where accuracy is of the essence, you’ll want to choose precision grinding every time. This comparison serves not to show which method of grinding is better, but the way the two complement one another by specializing in different areas of grinding.
Trust Summit Steel for Your Grinding Needs
Summit Steel has perfected the process of centerless grinding, a highly efficient precision grinding technique frequently used on steel tubes and bars. We also have the expertise to help you choose the right grinding process for your applications. Contact us for more information and a no-obligation grinding project quote today.